Another queen sacrifice might be in the works, this time in Virginia

How can a non-profit respond to financial stresses?  In non-profit higher education one response is to cut back on services and staff.

When a college or university does this, I call it a “queen sacrifice.”  That’s a term from chess, when a player gives up their most powerful piece – the queen – in a desperate move to win the game.  On campuses, tenure-track faculty often play this role, given their governance power and the long-term protections tenure provides, compared with adjunct faculty and all staff members.

buy grifulvin online buy grifulvin no prescription generic

  I’ve been tracking academic queen sacrifices for a long time now; click here for examples.

Today’s instance might come from Virginia’s Marymount University, which just announced a series of program cuts.  Programs the board wants to end include, according to Inside Higher Ed, bachelor’s “majors in art, economics, English, history, mathematics, philosophy, secondary education, sociology, and theology and religious studies, and an M.A. in English and humanities.”  The Washington Post adds that “A BA program in economics will be eliminated, but the BS in that field will remain.” (The changes haven’t appeared on the university’s majors web page yet.)

The reason cited for this move: low enrollment in those programs.  As president Becerra explains, “MU cannot financially sustain offering majors with consistently low enrollment, low graduation rates, and lack of potential for growth.”

Some students and faculty have protested the policy.  Many have noted the irony of a religious institution cutting theology and religious studies.

I hesitate to label this a queen sacrifice yet, because nobody’s been fired and no positions ended.  In another difference from the usual model, Marymount isn’t citing overall enrollment or financial problems.

So why bring this up at all? It may be that the program closures are all that’s to the story.  The majors and grad degrees end, finis.

Yet it’s worth looking closely.

buy furosemide online buy furosemide no prescription generic

Marymount University official building_official Flickr account

First, notice the nature of the programs.  A good chunk are in the humanities, so this can represent a datapoint in the continuing enrollment decline in that field.  If we extrapolate a bit, it might represent a shift from campuses offering full humanities programs to just having the humanities as service departments, teaching introductory classes only – i.e., Art Appreciation, Western Civ (for those who still do that), World History I, Introduction to Literature, etc.  That’s about one-sixth of all Marymount majors, according to the Chronicle of Higher Ed.

Also notice the cut to an education program.  This might strike some as perverse, given teacher shortages in much of the nation. I’ve seen teacher education programs cut in many queen sacrifices, and think it represents an important story. The field may just be losing its appeal, especially after the pandemic’s stresses. And some may be looking forward to continuing decline in the K-12 student population and not want to risk a career cut short in a decade or two.

Second, while I don’t know Marymount’s board, this may be a case of applied foresight. They may expect enrollment in those fields to keep declining, and hence want to not allocate resources without significant student demand.

Further, they may anticipate a larger problem if their university’s overall enrollment gets hit in the short or medium-term future.  Causes for this might be declining traditional-age student religiosity, anxiety or outrage at clerical sex abuse scandals (Marymount is a Catholic institution), growing public skepticism about higher ed, and, notably by Nathan Grawe’s upcoming demographic cliff (circa 2026).  Perhaps reducing the number of majors gives the board and senior administration freedom to not replace retirements, or to cut faculty when things get rough.

For a queen sacrifice to occur tenure-track faculty must be fired, and I don’t know enough about Marymount to make an informed guess if that’s in the offing.

buy propecia online buy propecia no prescription generic

  That’s the only way to save money, since personnel costs are academia’s biggest. Cutting majors can be a way of preparing the ground for cutting people.

buy avana online buy avana no prescription generic

Third point: beyond saving money by eventually cutting and/or not replacing staff, this decision might also allow the university to shift resources to academic programs it considers more likely to enroll more students. That doesn’t have to be done as a crisis strategy, but as part of a growth plan.  As statement emailed to a local news outlet put it, “Marymount will reallocate resources from those programs to others that better serve our students and reflect their interests.”

For now, another blow against the humanities and another campus to watch.

(campus photo from Marymount University’s official Flickr account)

Liked it? Take a second to support Bryan Alexander on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!
This entry was posted in higher education and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Another queen sacrifice might be in the works, this time in Virginia

  1. Jeff Graham says:

    I would be surprised if there isn’t an underlying financial problem driving this move.

  2. Ellen L Nuffer says:

    Often times, cuts in secondary education programs reflect a viewpoint that high school teachers only need to know the content that they teach, with the assumption that any pedagogy and understanding of adolescent learning will be “picked up on the job”. Those with this viewpoint often support programs like Troops to Teachers, or other alternative certification avenues. Queen sacrifice in the making, for sure, but also reflecting a perspective that is anti- teacher and anti- public school (IMHO).

  3. Donald Clark says:

    Good analysis. Not sure about the term ‘Queen Sacrifice’ here. These moves seem more like a bishop or knight sacrifice – some stuff off to the side that can be sacrificed without destroying the king, queen and castle. If we add course on to curricula we must surely consider taking some off.

  4. Pingback: Alarms Ringing: the disappearance of the college English major as individuals and as a discipline | Ellen And Jim Have A Blog, Two

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *